If you plan to use your baby carrier for everyday outings and not just special occasions, look for one that's comfortable for you and lightweight, washable, and easy to put on and take off. These considerations should factor into your decision much more heavily than style or price.
Baby Carriers Designed For Everyday Comfort: How to Choose Among the Types of Baby Carriers
The market offers four basic types of carriers: structured carriers, which feature heavy-duty padded straps and buckles and can look a bit like backpacks; soft carriers - which resemble shawls and are often made from woven cotton; hip carriers, which wrap around your waist and typically have room for a baby on either side of your body; and ring slings, which consist of a length of fabric with two rings at one end through which the other end feeds. Our tests have shown that the best carriers combine the ease of use and convenience of a structured carrier with the comfort and versatility of a soft carrier.
In other words, we recommend so-called hybrid carriers, or soft-structured carriers. We have tested hundreds of baby carriers over several years and found that models from brands like Líllébaby - Ergobaby, and BabyBJORN perform best in our tests. You should also consider the Solly Baby Wrap and the Beco Diamond Carrier, which each earned Excellent ratings in our tests.
Tips for Getting a Comfortable Fit With Your Carrier
It's important to get a comfortable fit with your carrier, both for your sake and your baby's. Make sure to read and follow the instructions, and consider asking a friend - family member, or store employee for a second opinion. Look for signs that your baby is comfortable and well supported, such as a calm demeanor, hips spread with knees above the hips, and arms supported at the shoulders. Be mindful of your own comfort - too, paying attention to whether the carrier puts pressure on any part of your body or causes rubbing or irritation.
Why Breastfeeding Support Is a Key Factor When Choosing a Carrier
One of the biggest benefits of using a baby carrier is that it can help promote breastfeeding. Across the studies we reviewed, the use of an ergonomic carrier was consistently associated with increased rates of exclusive breastfeeding, longer overall duration of any breastfeeding, and reduced rates of formula feeding. One study published in late 2022 found that breastfeeding rates among mothers who were given an ergonomic carrier during their prenatal care were twice as high as those of a control group.
This is significant - considering that suboptimal breastfeeding rates in the U.S. are associated with an estimated $3 billion in medical costs and $14.2 billion in costs related to premature deaths. Although the majority of new mothers intend to breastfeed their babies, less than half are still doing so by the time their babies are 6 months old. Many things can influence a mother's decision to discontinue breastfeeding earlier than she might like, including difficulties associated with returning to the workforce or school.
A baby carrier can help by making feedings quicker and easier, allowing mothers to keep their babies close while freeing up their hands to continue working. Some carriers even allow for discreet nursing. We found that the best carriers for everyday use accommodate both bottle- and breast-feeding easily and don't interfere with latching.
What to Know About Safety Standards for Baby Carriers
Baby carriers manufactured and imported in the United States are subjected to mandatory safety standards, substance restrictions - labeling, certification, and laboratory testing requirements set forth by the Consumer Product Safety Commission. The commission has investigated incidents of injury and death involving baby carriers and, more recently, issued a recall of thousands of baby carriers made with toxic chemicals. In addition to being compliant with federal regulations - look for carriers that meet or exceed the performance and safety standards set forth by the American Society for Testing and Materials. These standards include ASTM F2236, which applies to soft carriers and slings for children up to 22 pounds, and ASTM F2549, which applies to framed carriers for children between 15 pounds and 45 pounds.
A Realistic Approach to Price and Value
You don't necessarily need to spend a fortune on a baby carrier, but you shouldn't skimp on this investment entirely - either. Most parents we spoke with agreed that the best baby carriers are those that last through multiple children, hold their value, or can be passed down and reused.
Getting a Second Opinion Before You Buy
It's always a good idea to seek out a second opinion before buying a baby carrier. This can be from a friend or family member who has used baby carriers, or from a doula or other professional with expertise in this area. Some stores also offer classes or have experts on staff who can help you choose the right carrier and learn how to use it properly. We also found that manufacturers are usually readily accessible via email or phone and happy to answer questions about their products.
Disclaimer
This article is a personal reflection shared for general informational purposes only.
